20 Comments
User's avatar
Clare Frances's avatar

sounds like a lover reject song to me. maybe totally weird track she didn’t want to give up that has had many iterations through folkmore and then pop bliss. idk it doesn’t feel fresh to me (which is fine i like it), it feels too out of time and lived in

Eric H's avatar

I'm aware that YouTube's "what plays next" heuristic is highly user-dependent, but I would like to highlight that what autoplayed for me after this was the Richard Thompson version of "Season Of The Witch", which was a bit of a weird transition (that song is like ten minutes long and is a very slow build) (and has neither saxophone nor harmonica)

BDM's avatar

now I need to recreate this for myself

Sarah M.'s avatar

Baby, she is gonna win that Oscar! Great song. Someone check on Diane Warren! Also I LOVE the bridge in “I Think He Knows” so much that it makes me love the whole song. Lol also at chaos being saxophones.

BDM's avatar

we’re gonna get to EGO! EGO! EGO!

Sarah M.'s avatar

And when she wins a daytime Tony for producing an off Broadway play what then? She will finally be Tár. Let Me Be Your Tár.

BDM's avatar

other thought: this song is basically the emotional journey my dog goes through whenever I leave the house… "it's been a while" sir it's been ten minutes I just went to get the mail

G. Marie's avatar

The "leaving those days behind" bit sounds kinda ABBA to me!

BDM's avatar

it does!

sethdmichaels's avatar

really good song. my Swiftie gf and i listened to it several times last night and this morning; in addition to your point about her never making a song for a good movie, Emily said this is the first time she's made a good song for a movie. i love the 70s-y piano and sax - it kind of reminds me of a Natalie Prass song?

"Lover" is in my top 5 TS albums, so i'm an easy mark for this

BDM's avatar

of her movie songs I like “Carolina” and “Safe and Sound” a lot and “Sweeter Than Fiction” is cute. I have never listened to the song she made for Cats it feels too cursed.

Fran Hoepfner's avatar

I really like this song and I am also a "I Think He Knows" superfan. We few, we two.

"Crawdads" seems to me like a book TS would really like, tbh - she described her ideal novel on Colbert and I feel like it was kind of something Crawdads-adjacent, like, girl-oriented gothic crime/reckoning with past type of deal.

Clare Frances's avatar

me too

BDM's avatar

yeah that’s true. At the time it just felt so random to me.

Fran Hoepfner's avatar

It remains one of the most random movies to ever exist, somehow.

Elizabeth Power's avatar

when that movie came out I was spending the summer in new orleans and living a short walk away from a beautiful old single screen movie theater - every single day off I was like "ah, I should go to the prytania today!" but the only movie playing for the ENTIRE SUMMER was the accursed crawdads!!!! still resent that movie so much lmao but I do kind of like the song she wrote for it.

Emma's avatar

I was scared to listen (I have been dutifully steaming Niall) but I LOVE I Think He Knows. Will report back.

Fran Hoepfner's avatar

I need to listen to the Niall...

Emma's avatar

it’s a bunch of One Direction choruses! having fun!

BDM's avatar

they both make me want to hop around like a bunny that may be all they actually have in common but nevertheless